Macaron or macaroon? Reddit 52 week baking challenge (wk 10)

Macaron or macaroon? Reddit 52 week baking challenge (wk 10)

This week’s challenge in the reddit 52 weeks of baking challenge was to bake for an allergy or dietary restriction, and I knew I was headed for macaron practice. Macaron or macaroon? While both are flourless cookies, the macaroons I remember from my childhood – the post choir practice snack at the temple – were dense, heavy on the coconut, and very sweet. So very different from French macarons.

About a year ago, I made cocoa macarons for the first time (see pic below). They stuck to the Silpat, had hollow centers and no legs, and looked horrible. Filled with a chocolate frosting they tasted ok, which friends reassured me was the only metric. That’s why I’m the uglyducklingbakery, right?

A month or so later I tried again with caramel buttercream-filled macarons. This time they baked through, but the centers were still hollow, and they had no legs. I share these with you as proof that people aren’t always perfect on the internet.

What was I doing wrong? Did I overbeat the egg whites? Fold them in too aggressively? Wait to long for a skin to develop? Oven too hot? Oven too cold? I gave up. There were so many other things to bake that didn’t frustrate me half as much.

But then I joined the reddit challenge, and this week rolled around. I knew I would try again. I’m not the kind of person to give up, and I’m doing the reddit challenge to learn new baking skills. Never stop learning.

A supportive friend recommended I join the Everything Macarons Facebook Group. You know how some groups are nominally about one thing, but everyone goes off topic? Not this one. Everything about Everything Macarons is … macarons. All macarons. All of the time.

The group gave me a starting place for this week, which was the basic recipe from Indulge with Mimi. I followed the instructions. This recipe made me whip egg whites by a hand mixer instead of my stand mixer. It took a long time. I turned the bowl upside down over my head to confirm that they had reached firm peak stage (that’s how you tell, right?).

They developed a skin much more quickly than macarons in the past, and I baked them on parchment instead of a Silpat. They had legs!

I don’t know if any of those things made the difference. They’re far from perfect. But, without a doubt, filled with a peanut butter buttercream, they are delicious (Do ignore the colors. I have a young child who likes decorating…). I still need to work on my piping skills to get better rounds and flat tops. But whether macaron or macaroon, I’m confident that I passed this challenge.

On to the next one!

Previous challenges:
Week 1: New Year new recipe – blueberry galette
Week 2: seasonal – Smitten Kitchen’s grapefruit pound cake
Week 3: Great British Bake Off – Kate’s sticky toffee apple caramel cake
Week 4: Australia – sausage rolls
Week 5: bite sized – cookies
Week 6: Chinese New Year – mushroom bao
Week 7: new tool – baguette baker
Week 8: chocolate – chocolate peanut butter bonbons
Week 9: timed bake – under 1 hour! chocolate chip scones

Next week: quick breads

Follow uglyducklingbakery on your favorite social media platform.

Subscribe to the uglyducklingbakery newsletter!

4 thoughts on “Macaron or macaroon? Reddit 52 week baking challenge (wk 10)”

  • These are macarons, 100%. Macaroons are the coconut things you eat on Passover. I have been working on my earl grey, orange zest, chocolate chunk macaroons this year! And green peanut butter? Whoa!

    • Hillary, those sound divine. If you want feedback, the Everything Macarons facebook group seems to be full of experts who can help problem solve. re: the colors, kiddo decorates the same way she dresses. Combinations of patterns and bright colors. If only I were so bold!

  • I know this journey. I baked a dozen times before I was happy with the result. Nice feet on these. Did you double sift the dry? Like you, I would not quit until I had success. Oven temp-baking time—many factors, but worth all the effort when you see how pretty they can be. Thanks again for posting regularly and sharing your culinary adventures.

    • Hi Gale. Thanks so much for your comment and encouragement! I did double sift on these – first to sift the almond flour and powdered sugar into a bowl, and then again in the macronage (the mixing of the almond flour/sugar into the beaten egg whites) in order to minimize deflating the beaten whites.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.